Little relief for these migrant labourers as they stare at a long, hard struggle ahead

THE TRAGEDY OF MIGRANT LABOURERS

Support Citizen Matters - independent, Reader-funded media that covers your city like no other.
Get in-depth and insightful stories on issues that affect you every day!
Police distributing food to migrant labour in Kaushambi in NCR. Pic Pramod Pushkarna

After three days of hell on earth, Day 4 of the Narendra Modi decreed 21-day lockdown brought some relief to the thousands of migrant labourers in Kaushambi, a part of the NCR, but in Ghaziabad district of UP.


Reliable, useful journalism needs your support. 

Over 600 readers have donated over the years, to make articles like this one possible. We need your support to help Citizen Matters sustain and grow. Please do contribute today. Donate now


These migrant labourers from distant parts of UP in Kaushambi had been left in the lurch. Those who could had started to walk back to their homes, 700 km away. Till finally on March 28th, after a major debate on why a government that can bring home Indians stranded abroad cannot send its migrant workers home, the government relented and started limited bus services to different destinations in UP and Bihar.

A fleet of Delhi Transport Corporation buses ferried migrant labour from different parts of the national capital and even Gurugram in Haryana to Kaushambi, where UP state-owned public transport buses waited at the Interstate Bus Terminus, where UP begins. The mad rush to board the buses saw people grabbing hold of any hand and toe hold on the buses or finding sitting space on the rooftop.

Day 4 also finally saw migrant labour and their families get some relief from hunger. Thousands of migrants, men, women, children, old and young, were jostling for food that the police and the Shaheed Bhagat Singh Trust were providing, before they tried to push their way into the already overcrowded buses. Social distancing be damned.

Just one day earlier, on March 27th, the ground situation had been totally different. A group of 300-400 people living in the Bhawapur village had reached the UP State Bus Terminus, claiming a TV channel had announced that buses were available. The police had shooed them away saying there was no such service.

Migrant labour in these areas just outside Delhi have come from distant villages in UP and Bihar to earn a living any which way they can –cycling rickshaws, selling tea, cleaning cars at car parks, altering clothes on a leg machine parked on a pavement, sweeping factory floors, labourers at construction sites. They live in ghettos. They get to eat if they have earned that day.  And the flimsy roof  over can blow off on the whim of the “malik”.

Those who run cycle rickshaws are a wee bit luckier. They just bundle their women and children and their meagre bagful of utensils and clothes on to the rickshaw and find shelter wherever they can. Others stretch out on the pavements. They have, over time, learnt to deal with the usual irritants—the municipal corporation guys chasing them away, the police constable asking for their share and the RWAs who see them as criminals. Their numbers are anybody’s guess.

At the best of times, these migrant workers need no excuse to go home. The day they have enough money to buy their tickets to their village, they are ready to board the train from the Anand Vihar railway station–regardless of the loss of income when they are away.

But these are the worst of times. Most of them are literally penniless and cannot pay the bus fare back home, forget the Rs 500 that private operators are charging for a place on the roof. While the chances of their having come in contact with a Corona-carrying person are low, there is no data at all on this, or any study on how many of them may get affected if Stage 3 of the virus outbreak sets in. They have no water to wash their hands, let alone sanitisers. Most often, a dozen or more share a tiny tenement or jhuggi, so social distancing is out of the question.

Crush of people desperate to get aboard a bus that will take them home. Pic Pramod Pushkarna.

Rickshaw-puller Sunil Das from Muzaffarpur in Bihar has been working in the Maharajpur area near the Anand Vihar ISBT in East Delhi for the last 8-10 years. Three months back, he booked his train tickets for home for March 25th. When he got to the station and saw not a single train on the platform, he panicked. Finally he found a railway employee who told him all trains were cancelled, and he would get an SMS on refund of his tickets.

After returning to his room in Maharajpur, on Day 2 of the lockdown, with not a paisa on him, he came to the Kaushambi metro station, in the hope of picking up at least two passengers. No luck. Sunil then tried to take shelter at the Gurdwara in Madhu Vihar  — the nearest for him. But the police at the Delhi-UP border did not let him through. He did not walk to the Gurudwara as he was afraid that his rickshaw would be impounded. Since then, he has been pedaling his rickshaw between Kaushambi and Vaishali, his eyes desperate to sight a passenger. “How will we eat otherwise?” he asked.

That perhaps is the cruellest irony being faced by these migrant labours. Though just a few kilometres from Delhi, where CM Arvind Kejriwal has made elaborate arrangements to house and feed migrant labour and the homeless, people like Sunil are unable to get there as the border is closed.

Their own government is indifferent to their existence. Which explains their desperation to get back to their villages, where there is a possibility of getting some work when harvesting starts in a few weeks time, and where they will be eligible for the food packages announced.

Naresh Paswan, another rickshaw puller also from Maharajpur has been trying to cross the border into Delhi using sided roads and any other track his rickshaw can take. He wanted to reach the Ghazipur mandi nearby in the hope of buying some vegetables and selling them for a small profit, and if he was lucky, also pick up a passenger or two. While he could have walked across the border, he too did not want to leave his rickshaw, sure that the police would damage it.

People like Sunil and Paswan have no access to clean water either, despite working right in front of the Bisleri plant across the Kaushambi metro station. Some of them have had no food for the last few days and now do not have the energy to even ply their rickshaws.

The tragedy of these people is endless. Everyone has the same story to tell—no help where they are, and denied access to places in Delhi where they can get some help. And no money to catch the bus when it is available.

WE WANT TO THANK YOU
for reading Citizen Matters, of course. It would be fantastic to be able to thank you for supporting us as well. For 12 years we have strived to bring you trustworthy and useful information about our beloved Bengaluru. Because informed citizens are crucial to make a better city. Support Citizen Matters today.

DONATE NOW

About Vijaya Pushkarna 17 Articles
The author has not yet added any personal or biographical info to her or his author profile.

2 Comments

  1. An interesting article on an important topic. I read the article twice since I got confused after reading the article as you can see. I would appreciate if my doubts can be cleared. I am interested in the topic to understand how did AAP actually keep the promise of halving the power tariff while maintaining the fiscal balance. It almost sounds like we can have free lunch which cannot be true.

    “AAP had promised to halve the electricity bill. Mrs Bhalla’s bill was zero in Nov and Dec 2019. Malini who was paying Rs 6000 per month started to get a subsidy of Rs. 761 since August, 2019. Dinesh Kumar was getting zero bill for the last five to six months. Krtika Singh in Tilak Nagar has also been getting zero bills since August, 2019. AAP claims that it has reduced electricity bills by 50%.

    Article states at one place that subsidy announced was 20% up to 200 units, 35% from 201 to 400 units and zero after that.”

    I am giving the above quotes for my confusion.

    While the article giving the examples of Bhalla, Malini and Kumar creates an impression Delhi residents are getting “free electricity” since few months. Of course this is not true though the author ends up creating that impression at least in my case. Later the author after giving the new fixed charges shows how DERC reduced the fixed charges. There is no explanation as to how DERC reduced it. Since it is easy to reduce fixed charges by transferring to actual use through tariff increase, it would have been useful had the author explained why and how this happened. Did the government asked to reduce these fixed charges? After all some one has to pay it – either consumers through higher tariff or the government through higher subsidies or the generating/transmission companies by improving the efficiency or through reducing its rate of return.

    Having created the impression that AAP has met the promise of halving the electricity bill, it ends by showing how actual bill has reduced only by 18.56% for consumers with 2KW load, and by 28.43% for consumers with 5 KW. What happened to the implied claim of 50% savings?

    I agree that AAP has certainly reduced power bill by doling out subsidy. But as we all know there is no free lunch in this world. What impact this had on the budget? On the other hand if we find out that AAP managed to reduce power bill without having a “significant” impact on the budget (you told me that they even had a surplus) then one needs to appreciate it.

    Look forward to getting some explanation.

    regards
    Bhamy

  2. The AAP manifesto indeed said they would halve the electricity bills. People did not believe they would be able to implement the subsidy. Today it is not half for all, it is free for some and a saving of about Rs800 for those who consume less than 400 units, and absolutely no subsidy for those who consume more than 400 units.

    When they assumed office in 2013, they spelt out the subsidies– 20% up to 200 units, 35% from 201 to 400 units and zero after that. It would have reduced the bills to half for some, not all power consumers, but the government was gone in 49 days. When Arvind Kejriwal returned to power in 2015, it continued that way, and so there was no buzz about the power subsidy.

    That is when, in Aug 2019—a few months before the assembly elections of Feb 2020 –, the Delhi government tweaked the scheme, announcing a 100 per cent subsidy for those who consume up to 200 units for power a month, and Rs 800 off their bills for those consuming between 201 to 400 units. It is since then that the bills came to zero for those who consumed less than 200 units, and others got a subsidy of 800 rupees. It helped that October, November weather in the capital is very pleasant: you don’t need ACs or heaters, so many people saved Rs800 a month. Those who ran up over 400 units got no subsidy.

    The DERC is mandated to fix the tariff –fixed load charges as well as power tariff for consumers, so it did, not from their pockets or reducing the price they pay. The gap on account of the subsidy was bridged by the Delhi government through budgetary allocations.

    The Delhi government has paid for the power subsidy without impacting their budget adversely, and they say, it is their prudence –no frivolous expenses on themselves, Now, the Congress has said they will give free electricity upto 300 units, and the BJP has said they will continue to the AAP subsidies on power if elected!

1 Trackback / Pingback

  1. What do the manifestos of AAP, BJP and INC promise for Delhi elections 2020? | Citizen Matters

Comments are closed.