Delhi: 45 sanitation workers test positive for COVID, 15 succumb, but where are the yellow bins?

DISPOSAL AND HANDLING OF BIOMEDICAL WASTE DURING COVID-19

Support Citizen Matters - independent, Reader-funded media that covers your city like no other.
Get in-depth and insightful stories on issues that affect you every day!
In the absence of any awareness around proper disposal of COVID waste, PPEs and other biomedical waste lie strewn around indiscriminately.

Pre-Covid, Delhi’s crematoriums used to be littered with heaps of withered marigold, broken bits of earthen pots, tetrapac containers containing ghee and mineral water bottles.


Reliable, useful journalism needs your support. 

Over 600 readers have donated over the years, to make articles like this one possible. We need your support to help Citizen Matters sustain and grow. Please do contribute today. Donate now


Today, even as COVID has made cremation of bodies a challenge in itself and sharply restricted attendance at funerals, the garbage dumped at these sites is becoming dangerous — consisting mainly of biomedical waste as people carelessly strew their PPE body suits, masks, gloves, shoe covers etc that they wore to the funeral.

Such are the proportions of the problem that on June 22nd, the South Delhi Municipal Corporation slapped a Rs 50,000 penalty on the Arya Samaj which manages the Lodhi Road crematorium in south Delhi, one of the five designated COVID crematoriums in the city.

The penalty itself was only a token move, considering that the SDMC had on that day pressed into service 12 trucks and staff who had to work till late into the night to clear the crematorium and its parking area of discarded PPE kits.

The Central Pollution Control Board (CPCB) estimates that Delhi generates at least 11 tonnes of Covid related biomedical waste daily, with every possibility of this number increasing over the next few weeks. 

PPEs and other biomedical waste strewn indiscriminately at Delhi’s Lodi Road crematorium.

From the street children at traffic signals to VVIPs, everyone in the city — as indeed in the country — knows the importance of wearing a mask, saying “Namaste” instead of shaking hands, and maintaining “Do gaz ki Doori”. But few have seen a yellow dustbin let alone know why there should be one, along with the blue and green ones at home, or in public places.

The CPCB, in colour coding different types of garbage, has chosen yellow bags and yellow bins for the collection and trashing of biomedical wastes. While most big hospitals and labs have yellow bins, they are nowhere to be seen public spaces.

Dangers from mixed waste

There has been no awareness building around COVID-generated biomedical waste and how to safely deal with it. Households have an idea about the need to separate their wet waste from dry waste, with electronic waste forming a third category. But municipal corporations have not told people about the need to have a third bin – to dispose used masks, PPEs, shoe covers, and gloves.

At the best of times, managing the capital’s mounting mounds of  garbage has been a nightmare. Now, when the city is listed as a COVID hotspot, no one know hows much of the biomedical waste generated daily because of the pandemic has landed in landfills, though municipal corporation officials admit it has. Their explanation is the poor and tardy segregation of waste at source.

One pointer to the fact that contaminated COVID biowaste has got mixed with the general waste is that over 45 sanitation workers have tested positive with 37 in hospital, and according to the Delhi Safai Karamchari Association, about 15 of them have died. The association president Sanjay Gahlot has no doubt that these workers got the virus from handling contaminated waste.

Though there is basic awareness that containing the virus depends greatly on proper sanitation and hygiene, that the virus spread is also related to scientific waste management has not gained public attention.

“Waste management comes at Number 1,” says independent waste management expert Swati Sambyal. In her view, leaving aside the New Delhi Municipal Corporation area that is Lutyens’ Delhi from where the Government of India governs the country, the rest of Delhi does not segregate its garbage.

With increasing instances of asymptomatic people testing positive, this kind of mixed waste can create havoc, say experts. Especially since many sanitation workers who collect household waste are not always wearing masks, or are wearing masks discarded by others or which they have picked up from the garbage. And hardly any of them wear gloves, let alone any PPEs.

“Ideally they should be given a new mask every day,” says Sambyal. “They are directly exposed as they are dealing with mixed waste and sorting it. There are protocols in disposing such PPEs.”

For instance, a mask should be ripped up, wrapped and given to the collector separately, to ensure nobody uses them again. Creating awareness on the dangers involved in handling such waste and how to correctly dispose of PPEs is the challenge.

A resident of West Delhi’s Punjabi Bagh who did not want to be named says the residents and their RWA have not been informed of any new or different way of handing over household waste to the sanitation worker. “Earlier we used to segregate wet and dry waste,” she said. “Now the collector has told us not to bother, because he will bring the bag for wet waste one day, and one for the dry waste the next day. And they are in a great hurry to collect and leave”.

Incidentally, they have not heard of a yellow bin, or the need to segregate masks, gloves etc from other waste nor are they aware that biomedical wastes generated by COVID related health protocols cannot be treated like other biomedical waste.

“There are senior citizens using diapers, there are sanitary pads, cotton swabs and babies’ diapers,” says Malini Sivaram a member of the sub committee on waste segregation at the Azad Apartments adjoining the Delhi IIT campus. Azad Apartments is one of seven societies chosen for focused segregation of waste. “We don’t know who is  asymptomatic, who has mild symptoms and who is self-quarantining.”

Given the difficulties in getting tests done and finding hospital beds, Malini says many are trying to deal with flu symptoms on their own. On her part, she has asked residents to discard the masks they have used separately and urged the RWA to get in touch with the SDMC for detailed information of waste segregation in the light of Covid. “The guidelines we received last week were no different from what we had been following for over a year”.

As the government now clearly wants patients with mild or no symptoms to stay in home isolation, a fresh set of guidelines to the public and sanitation workers on collection, segregation and disposal of biomedical waste is particularly urgent.

What the Municipal Corporations say

The five local bodies – the municipal corporations of North Delhi, South Delhi, East Delhi, and New Delhi Municipal and the Delhi Cantonment Board – say they have devised systems to manage this issue.

North Delhi Municipal Corporation deputy commissioner Ira Singhal says every time they receive information of a new positive case or a case of  Covid care centre advised-home isolation, the address is conveyed to the garbage collection team. “A team of three in PPE kits collect the garbage in double-layered yellow bags as prescribed by the CPCB,” said Ira Singhal. “These bags are first disinfected with sodium hypochloride and then deposited in the processing facility. We have collected and disposed of almost 20 tonnes of biomedical waste so far”.

The other municipal corporations say they too have similar arrangements, and collectors reaching different addresses say they follow the guidelines conveyed to them.

Though he has not collected biomedical waste so far, Shyam Sunder who collects garbage from Parpatganj in East Delhi was aware of the yellow, double layered bags in which they collect garbage from containment zones. “But we don’t have the time to tell people to segregate, and cannot threaten them that we will leave their garbage, so we pick them up in whatever state it is,” says Shyam Sunder.

In containment zones, sanitation workers and garbage collectors do enter wearing  PPE kits. “We collect and treat all waste as contaminated bio medical waste”, said a door-to-door garbage collector at Shahdara in east Delhi.

The CPCB under the Environment Ministry first issued “Guidelines for Handling, Treatment and Disposal of Waste Generated during Treatment/Diagnosis/ Quarantine of COVID-19 patients,” on March 18th and has revised it thrice since.

From a 4-page document in March, the guidelines now run into 10 pages. But it is only in the latest revision of June 10th, that the CPCB for the first time listed among the duties of Urban Local Bodies (ULBs), a clause involving citizens.

“Create awareness among citizens regarding segregation of municipal solid waste and biomedical waste (as part of Domestic Hazardous Waste) generated from homes/quarantine homes/home care facilities”. A line that has so far remained on paper.

Needed, a decentralised waste disposal system

“Delhi’s waste management is handled by a private company which has signed an agreement with the municipality to collect and dispose the waste,” says Swati Sambyal. An agreement with the common biomedical waste treatment company typically details the services sought and bought by the government which includes collection, transportation, treatment and disposal of the waste, barcoding, advanced tracking of the biomedical garbage from the point of generation to the final disposal, and integrated waste collection services including waste storage, manpower and PPEs.

The Delhi government has signed up with Biotic Waste Solutions Pvt Ltd which has six biomedical waste management facilities in north India. It handles everything from collection to final disposal of the waste. 

Delhi has two biomedical waste management facilities of Biotic, one each at Okhla and Neelothi, with an installed capacity of 13 and 19 tons a day respectively. Their work is overseen by the Delhi Biomedical Waste Management Cell formed under the Delhi government’s Directorate General of Health Services. Ahead of the pandemic, the Delhi Pollution control Committee said 13,641.22 kgs of biomedical waste was generated daily. 

“Cities that have decentralised collection, like in Bengaluru, have more active citizen and volunteers groups, NGOs, all involved in creating awareness,” says Swati. “In a centralised system, Delhi’s residents have nothing to do with their waste…just hand it over to someone else, with little awareness of the changed circumstance. In cities where civic groups, NGOs and volunteer groups are active, they have more effective action to prevent contamination from the covid related waste”.

While biomedical waste from hospitals and COVID care centres and quarantine facilities are collected and treated separately from the other biomedical waste, in Delhi’s residential areas, from the upmarket South Delhi to the very poor near the Gazipur landfill, no such segregation is happening.

According to Swati, “Neither the people nor the collectors seem to be aware of the need for a  third bin — for hazardous household waste. According to the Central Pollution Control Board guidelines used masks and gloves from households should be kept in a paper bag for at least 72 hours before being disposed of as general waste”. Few residents comply with this, even discarding used PPEs they buy to visit a hospital or attend a funeral, in their dustbins at home. 

Incidentally, biomedical waste management is an important segment in the training  being imparted to “Covid Warriors” — from doctors to nodal officers of the government, associations, nurses, dentists, pharmacists, ayush personnel and asha workers, everyone involved in the effort to track, trace and treat Covid patients.

In fact, four years ago, the administration had come out with a 253-page “SOP For Infection Prevention & Control in Healthcare Settings,” which pretty much covers everything that the government is trying to do in its fight against COVID — from the use of PPEs and masks and gloves by people dealing with biomedical waste to their safe disposal, everything is already there.

Except for creating awareness among people on this, especially now.

WE WANT TO THANK YOU
for reading Citizen Matters, of course. It would be fantastic to be able to thank you for supporting us as well. For 12 years we have strived to bring you trustworthy and useful information about our beloved Bengaluru. Because informed citizens are crucial to make a better city. Support Citizen Matters today.

DONATE NOW

About Vijaya Pushkarna 17 Articles
The author has not yet added any personal or biographical info to her or his author profile.

2 Comments

  1. An interesting article on an important topic. I read the article twice since I got confused after reading the article as you can see. I would appreciate if my doubts can be cleared. I am interested in the topic to understand how did AAP actually keep the promise of halving the power tariff while maintaining the fiscal balance. It almost sounds like we can have free lunch which cannot be true.

    “AAP had promised to halve the electricity bill. Mrs Bhalla’s bill was zero in Nov and Dec 2019. Malini who was paying Rs 6000 per month started to get a subsidy of Rs. 761 since August, 2019. Dinesh Kumar was getting zero bill for the last five to six months. Krtika Singh in Tilak Nagar has also been getting zero bills since August, 2019. AAP claims that it has reduced electricity bills by 50%.

    Article states at one place that subsidy announced was 20% up to 200 units, 35% from 201 to 400 units and zero after that.”

    I am giving the above quotes for my confusion.

    While the article giving the examples of Bhalla, Malini and Kumar creates an impression Delhi residents are getting “free electricity” since few months. Of course this is not true though the author ends up creating that impression at least in my case. Later the author after giving the new fixed charges shows how DERC reduced the fixed charges. There is no explanation as to how DERC reduced it. Since it is easy to reduce fixed charges by transferring to actual use through tariff increase, it would have been useful had the author explained why and how this happened. Did the government asked to reduce these fixed charges? After all some one has to pay it – either consumers through higher tariff or the government through higher subsidies or the generating/transmission companies by improving the efficiency or through reducing its rate of return.

    Having created the impression that AAP has met the promise of halving the electricity bill, it ends by showing how actual bill has reduced only by 18.56% for consumers with 2KW load, and by 28.43% for consumers with 5 KW. What happened to the implied claim of 50% savings?

    I agree that AAP has certainly reduced power bill by doling out subsidy. But as we all know there is no free lunch in this world. What impact this had on the budget? On the other hand if we find out that AAP managed to reduce power bill without having a “significant” impact on the budget (you told me that they even had a surplus) then one needs to appreciate it.

    Look forward to getting some explanation.

    regards
    Bhamy

  2. The AAP manifesto indeed said they would halve the electricity bills. People did not believe they would be able to implement the subsidy. Today it is not half for all, it is free for some and a saving of about Rs800 for those who consume less than 400 units, and absolutely no subsidy for those who consume more than 400 units.

    When they assumed office in 2013, they spelt out the subsidies– 20% up to 200 units, 35% from 201 to 400 units and zero after that. It would have reduced the bills to half for some, not all power consumers, but the government was gone in 49 days. When Arvind Kejriwal returned to power in 2015, it continued that way, and so there was no buzz about the power subsidy.

    That is when, in Aug 2019—a few months before the assembly elections of Feb 2020 –, the Delhi government tweaked the scheme, announcing a 100 per cent subsidy for those who consume up to 200 units for power a month, and Rs 800 off their bills for those consuming between 201 to 400 units. It is since then that the bills came to zero for those who consumed less than 200 units, and others got a subsidy of 800 rupees. It helped that October, November weather in the capital is very pleasant: you don’t need ACs or heaters, so many people saved Rs800 a month. Those who ran up over 400 units got no subsidy.

    The DERC is mandated to fix the tariff –fixed load charges as well as power tariff for consumers, so it did, not from their pockets or reducing the price they pay. The gap on account of the subsidy was bridged by the Delhi government through budgetary allocations.

    The Delhi government has paid for the power subsidy without impacting their budget adversely, and they say, it is their prudence –no frivolous expenses on themselves, Now, the Congress has said they will give free electricity upto 300 units, and the BJP has said they will continue to the AAP subsidies on power if elected!

1 Trackback / Pingback

  1. What do the manifestos of AAP, BJP and INC promise for Delhi elections 2020? | Citizen Matters

Comments are closed.